“I will buy with you, sell with you, talk with you, walk with you, and so following; but I will not eat with you, drink with you, nor pray with you” (Shakespeare I. iii. 28-30).
When Bassanio goes to Shylock in search of economic aid, he addresses Shylock with both respect and kindness. In addition, he invites Shylock to dine with him, yet Shylock responds with a harsh and bitter reply. He not only rejects Bassanio’s invitation, but he also lists all that he would and would not do with Bassanio. Shylock declares he will never “eat,” “drink,” or “pray” with Bassanio, all of which he decides to never do because of their different religious beliefs. Instead of reciprocating Bassanio’s present gentleness towards him, Shylock’s tone in response is interpreted to be very hostile. Shakespeare’s use of repetition makes Shylock ironically appear directive, as if he is superior to Bassanio; meanwhile, Bassanio is technically more respected and recognized in Venetian society than Shylock. However, although Shakespeare has not included a moment when Bassanio has been rancorous towards Shylock or other Jews, one questions whether Shylock’s aggression can be justified. Is it Shylock who should control his bellicosity to those who deserve it, or is Shylock unconcerned with his behavior to Bassanio because he knows he is only kind since he needs help?
Jacky--A wonderful "unpacking" of the lines you quote. Exactly the kind of stuff you should be doing here. Well-written and intelligent. Keep it up!
ReplyDelete